Airline passenger news and views

A DMR Service

19 May 2012 |

News & Articles Comments  

Alarming report on pilot fatigue

Noel Hernandez Noel Hernandez
Tuesday 19 April 2011

Nearly a half of Britain's airline pilots suffer significant fatigue, a team from University College of London (UCL) has found, as showed in a report published in early April.

sleeping-pilot1.jpgThe study, led by Professor Andrew Steptoe and commissioned by the British Airline Pilots' Association (BALPA), has been done on a sample of 492 pilots - two third of them captains - and it has concluded that a 45% were suffering a significant fatigue.

Although the Civil Aviation Authority does allow the pilots to fly discretionary hours to deal with difficult situations, that is supposed to be an exception and not the norm. Instead, 40 per cent of the pilots found themselves  having to fly more than the regulation hours at least twice a month to cope with the volume of flights, according to the UCL study.

Even more worrying is the revelation of that "one in five pilots reported that their abilities were compromised in flight more than once a week."

Jim McAuslan, BALPA general secretary has commented: 'Fatigue amongst British pilots is growing, as this study shows and as our members know. UK pilots have also been giving personal testimonies about their own experience of fatigue and what it feels like to be pushed to the limits. These are enough to make the hairs stand up on the back of your neck, even under current fatigue regulations. To force them to fly still more hours is, frankly, reckless.'

This study comes to reinforce what previous ones had already acknowledged. That factors such as irregular sleep and work patterns cause disruption of the circadian rhythm in pilots who fly into discretionary hours, contributing to aircrew fatigue.

Pilot fatigue is an acknowledged contributory risk factor to aircraft accidents. And it was a major element in the Colgan disaster on 12th February 2009, when 50 were killed in an airliner which crash-landed at Buffalo, USA, as the investigations showed.

Fatigue might induce in pilots episodes of "microsleep," a term that defines periods that last from a few seconds to several minutes in which the person fails to respond to outside information. Those episodes often occur when the person's eyes are open. During a microsleep, a pilot might not be aware of flashing alarm lights in the cockpit.

The UCL team's recommendations include better scheduling to take pressure off pilots and more transparent fatigue reporting systems.

John
John, Maidstone
19 April 2011, 12:52PM

Certainly an un-enviable job for pilots to maintain regular healthy sleeping patterns with the hours and multiple time-zones they cover. Lets hope the CAA tightens the regulations governing pilot working hours.

  Rating (0)
Graham Austin
Graham Austin, Leeds, UK
19 April 2011, 01:45PM

I am a very well qualified private pilot with a commercial licence and I can confirm that this happens. It has happened to me as a co-pilot with the pilot and I both asleep for what was probably only a minute.
This was not fatigue, it was flying out of Naples to Cyprus in perfect weather with the warm sun in our faces. Sometimes the safer the flight and the less you have to do, the more the risk of too much relaxation.
The good news it that it only happened once.

  Rating (0)
Mrs Kent
Mrs Kent
24 April 2011, 12:43PM

I am not a nervous flyer but reports of this nature do worry me. How do we know what they re doing up in the cockpit? They could be asleep of gassed or anything and we would not know.

  Rating (0)
Martin Humphries
Martin Humphries
24 April 2011, 11:56PM

I am not convinced that this happens much on scheduled flights in Europe. The airways like the roads are just too busy and they have a lot of air traffic control work to do.
I can however believe that it happens on the long cross-water routes where their reporting is less frequent and the plane is just on autopilot for long periods.

  Rating (0)
Chris McCloud
Chris McCloud, Scotland
9 May 2011, 08:15PM

There ought to be some technology for this. Can they not monitor heart rate or breathing or something like that and then sound an alarm to wake the pilots up.

  Rating (0)
Kerry Ann
Kerry Ann, Windsor
8 August 2011, 03:07PM

My partner has until recently been working for a major airline,not low cost. I have heard many times of exhausted pilots who end up sleeping during flights. It seems 4 hour ones in Europe are worst.

  Rating (0)
Name *
Location
E-mail
Comment *