Airline passenger news and views

A DMR Service

19 May 2012 |

News & Articles Comments  

Overweight passengers re-visited

Catriona Wells Catriona Wells
Friday 4 February 2011

Last year, I wrote an article - Too big for his seat - about an overweight co-passenger on a flight back from Italy.  It generated a fair amount of comment at the time but I now see that the topic has been re-opened in the guise of ambulances and hospital facilities for over-weight patients.

British people are getting bigger! we will soon be up there with our American cousins as a nation of the obese. Too many burgers, too little exercise and perhaps, too much sitting in front of TV and computer screens.

As the headline ran, “Re-sizing Britain” with the need for bigger hospital beds, larger ambulances and stretchers, and the knock-on consequences of stronger bed lifts and re-enforced examination tables.

If you are not directly affected, it is easy to see the funny side of much of this. But, there are some pretty serious implications. Hospitals are now regularly dealing with people weighing 30-stone.  Some of these are clinically obese and some are relatively fit and well but “big boned” as we used to say.

The serious concern is that if you have an accident and need medical help, you may simply not fit the profile for care.  Ambulance crews may not be able to move you. OK, some of this is due to Health and Safety considerations but even with a willing crew, a 30-stone unconscious patient has to be a challenge.

Very sadly, there were reports last year of a 30-stone gentleman who died of a heart attack leaving his wife with the problem of finding an undertaker and a crematorium that could accept his body. It would seem that there are limits on coffin sizes and the authorized capacity of crematoria.

Perhaps, we have to expect airlines to pick up on this and make passenger weight a factor in the ticket price calculation.

I think we may also have to revisit the question of luggage worn as clothing. See my colleague Eugene Gold's article from July 2010 Stuff your pockets and stuff security.

Louisa Danes
Louisa Danes, Angmering, West Sussex
8 February 2011, 01:10PM

Part of me feels a little saddened by the vast majority of overweight individuals in today’s society. They have been brought down by the quick and easy foods now available in our shops and pushed to the masses by our advertising! High in sugar or fat and low in anything nutritional, who is really to blame, the consumers or the country which pushes these products?? Perhaps a tighter leash on what goes into what we sell on our shelves would be time better spent instead of focusing on accommodating our growing nation?

  Rating (0)
Joanne
Joanne, Eltham
10 February 2011, 10:08PM

There are some rediculous cases out there which just seem to be growing and the professionals are not fully equipped to deal with it. I also think it will b a long time before we see this country adapt.

  Rating (0)
Freya Williams
Freya Williams, Cornwall
10 February 2011, 11:34PM

Having gone through some of the comments from the original overweight article it makes me want to ask these people if they own their own pitchforks! No one chooses to be overweight or at least over the "socially accepted" weight. Many people suffer from medical or mental disorders. Airline seats have never been that great to begin with but yay to all those discriminating their follow man in favour of some cms of comfort, really it should be your adorned airlines which should be ridiculed for their thrifting!

  Rating (0)
Pat Heath
Pat Heath, London
13 February 2011, 04:53PM

I am not knocking the overweight but, if you are sitting next to one of them, then that person is a nuisance.
I do not mind whether you blame medical or mental disorders or if you blame the airline for making the seats too small but the fact is that you have an uncomfortable journey and possibly a less safe one.

  Rating (0)
Drew
Drew, Dorset
14 February 2011, 02:01PM

Lets remember that we are all humans and have feelings. The comments made by some are so nasty it makes me wonder if the individuals making the comments have ever experienced any health problems in their life. I have lived with obesity all my adult life and have tried so many times to lose weight, alongside the obesity comes depression and I have on several occasions tried to take my own live. I feel like my whole life has been one battle and could do without reading such negative comments. I would never have the confidence to board a plane for fear of being ridiculed.

  Rating (0)
Nicola
Nicola, Kent
15 February 2011, 11:40AM

I am fat not obese and I find airline seats far to small. However I do not think this is a problem just for overweight people, I have been listening to a slim colleague who has just travelled back to the UK from Hong Kong and even he said how cramped the seating was. Lets not just aim this topic at overweight humans as it even affects the slimmest of people.

  Rating (0)
Diane
Diane, Bexley
16 February 2011, 08:02AM

I can not get over people who refer to an over weight person as 'one of them' like they are a socially unaccepted race!

  Rating (0)
Les
Les, Crayford
17 February 2011, 12:34PM

I am overweight and recently went to visit my parents who live abroad. I was treated like a second-class citizen, but not buy the airline staff by other travellers, when is society going to accept that we aren't all perfect?

  Rating (0)
Sally Thomas
Sally Thomas, Essex
17 February 2011, 04:20PM

I do think people can do something about their size. I was overweight for a long time, but I got very embarrassed especially when flying. I decided to do something about it. The trouble is people are too afraid to speak their mind these days, and the discussion of obesity and making comments about others is almost a taboo subject. Why should people put up with being made uncomfortable when they are flying? I took the step, so can others.

  Rating (0)
Trish
Trish, Sandown
21 February 2011, 05:08PM

I saw today on the front page of a tabloid that a 17-year-old girl is 40 stone. How on earth has she been allowed to get to that size? I know every case is different but in this instance surely her parent have to take a large chunk of the responsibility.

  Rating (0)
Michelle
Michelle, Margate
14 March 2011, 01:45PM

I totally agree with Trish, this is totally unacceptable! Surely it is a form of abuse? I would be interested to see how her flight to America was she went there for treatment.

  Rating (0)
Dave Bourne
Dave Bourne
5 April 2011, 05:34PM

Very little of this argument is about fatties, it is about the effect of fatties on other people and on safety in general.
I do not care whether they are fat, thin, tall or short but if it means that I cannot sit properly in my seat or get out of it in an emergency then it does become my business.

  Rating (0)
name withheld
name withheld
7 April 2011, 01:17PM

I sympathise with both sides in this debate. I have a friend that is very large for medical rather than gluttony reasons. I also recognise that she could be a danger to other passengers in the event of an accident.

  Rating (0)
Name *
Location
E-mail
Comment *